The Cold Justice team had worked on the case with local law enforcement several months earlier. Thats what Siegler and her rotating roster of investigators Steve Spingola, Tonya Rider, and Abbey Abbondandolo do. Digital forensics expert Eric Devlin analyzed text messages between Anita and the suspects. Exclusive updates on past cases and questions to Kelly and Yolanda will be featured. He was shot at the top of the head and this side of the face, said Hook. John 'Jay' Sallee was just 31 years old when murdered, in this 24 year old cold case. Hewas questioned in 1988 over Smiths disappearancebut was not charged with the murder,the outlet reports. Can the team finally bring justice to his grieving family? But according to authorities and witnesses interviewed on Cold Justice, as many as five people may have been involved in Jones murder. The shows team also brought cutting-edge new technology to the investigation and more than 50 witnesses were interviewed,thePalestine Herald reported. When they drove to Nicholes residence, her father was there. A trial date has not been set, according to local law enforcement. ', 'Newsreaders' & More", "Friday Cable Ratings: 'Alaskan Bush People' Tops Night + 'Gold Rush', 'Jack & Triumph Show', NBA Basketball & More", "Friday Cable Ratings: 'Gold Rush' Wins Night, 'Bring It! New information came to lightandpointed to Charles asaviable suspect in the murder. When the police arrived, she was dead from being shot in the head. In this I-Team special report, we lay out the case of Dawn's death and renew investigators and prosecutors plea for information leading to the arrest and conviction of her killer. Cold Justice is produced by Wolf Entertainment & Magical Elves. Police have not revealed the exact details of what led to Joinersarrest,but they did mention working closely with Cold Justice and other law enforcement teamshelpedbreak the case. To learn more about the work of the intrepid team of investigators and how they are helping local law enforcement move other cases forward, watch Cold Justice, which returns to Oxygen on Saturday, September 3 at 8/7c. Charlene and son Gary developed a combative relationship after Gary's father and Charlene's husband, Willy, died in a tragic accident. Ricky Luebbert, a 42-year-old volunteer fireman, was murdered on Nov. 10, 2007 at his home in Texas County, near Tyrone, Missouri. S3, Ep23. Suspect Terrance Staley plead guilty to fraud for stealing $600 from her credit card but claimed to not have anything to do with her murder. Linette Felts is the prime suspect of Steven Felts's murder case. Your First Look at the New Season of Cold Justice, Kelly Siegler and Cold Justice Team Break Down How They Approach Cases in CrimeCon Event, Kelly Siegler and Detective Carmen Asham Talk Small-Town Floods, Cold Justice returns with six new episodes beginning, Sept. 3 at 8 p.m. ET/PTPutnam County, Fla. A Mothers Last Words(90 minutes), |Kelly and Abbey investigate the brutal slaying of a pregnant woman who was able to call 911 but died before naming her killer. ', NBA Basketball, 'Preachers'Daughters' & More", "Fla. man gets life after TV show uncovers wife's murder", "Updated: ShowBuzzDaily's Top 25 Friday Cable Originals: 3.6.2015", "ShowBuzzDaily's Top 25 Friday Cable Originals (& Network Updates): 4.10.2015", "Flanders gets 15 years for manslaughter", "UPDATE: Bones found buried in FWB yard confirmed those of Marie Carlson", "Friday Cable Ratings: 'NBA Playoffs' Win Night, 'Bring It! Allen told local media that Stacey was a wonderful woman: She was the person that, if you were having a bad day, go talk to her and I promise youll walk away with her smile, he said,local station KAIT8reported. In a significant determination, investigators noted that the front door wasnt a push turn lock it could only be locked with a key. The case has a trial call date set for August 29, 2022, according to the State Attorneys Office communications director. The team searches for justice 22 years later. The episode goes over Humphrey's death and the suspects surrounding his murder, but no one has been convicted of the crime just yet. In March 2022, the Minot Police arrested 34-year-old Nichole Rice, who was living with Knutson at the time of her murder. From Executive Producer Dick Wolf, Tom Thayer and Magical Elves, the true crime investigative series follows veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler, and her rotating team of seasoned detectives Steve Spingola, Tonya Rider and Abbey Abbondandolo, as they travel to small towns to dig into unsolved homicide cases that have lingered for years without answers or justice for the victims. The White Settlement, Texas, investigation continues. Were they trying to get her out of town for a fresh start? Siegler theorized. He lived out of state and wasnt considered a suspect, but it was a possible motive behind the slaying. They also discovered Joe had a life insurance policy for $600,000. Cold Justice is an investigative true crime series originally broadcast on TNT and currently on Oxygen. Cold Justice Season 1 (174) 8.0 2013 NR Criminals who think they can get away with murder are in for a rude awakening as two women who have spent their lives putting killers behind bars set out to crack long-unsolved cases in TNT's real life crime series Cold Justice. Kelly & Johnny Bonds work with the Jasper County Sheriffs Department, Texas to take on the May 2012 disappearance of a 56-year-old mother, Kay L. McCoy. Fifteen years after the slaying, they were able to help the Minot Police Department make an arrest. Hewas arrested and charged with second-degree murder on June 8,2019,Fort Myers Policeannounced. One of them, Tyler Schmaltz, was eventually determined to be a harmless crush, said Siegler. Cold Case December 28 A look back at 2022: Five of the top cold cases solved A combination of DNA technology and genetic genealogy allowed law enforcement authorities to solve a number of. Kelly and Steve Spingola investigate the brutal slaying of beloved mother Eloise Payne, who was stabbed 38 times in her Michigan home. What's next? They are also persons of interest in her disappearance. They determined theyhad sufficient circumstantial evidence suggesting that Nichole killed Anita to present to the prosecutor. They determined they. Detective Usina set up a meeting with the states attorney to run down the case, said Siegler. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. On October 22, 2019, Ashley, then 42, was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. To learn more about this case and others like it, watch Cold Justice,which you can stream here. Rhonda Poche-Johnson told Oxygen.com. Kelly and Steve head into Louisiana to work with the Concordia Parish Sheriffs Office and investigate the 2016 homicide of a 26-year-old whose body was found on the banks of the bayou. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! "I don't knowwhetherto get happy or to cry," she said, after learning of Joiners arrest. In a March 2022 Minot Daily News article, local Police Chief John Klug cited help from Cold Justice in helping to move forward on the case. The Cold Justice team brought in new expertsto put fresh eyes on the case,and helped investigators conduct interviews with more than 50 witnesses,the News-Press reported. had sufficient circumstantial evidence suggesting that Nichole killed Anita to present to the prosecutor. The case of Tanai Jones, a 21-year-old college student who was stabbed and shot to death in Paterson, New Jersey in 2000. The exchanges painted a pretty clear picture of escalating tension between the two young women, said Siegler, although in the initial 2007 investigation, Nichole downplayed the divide between her and Anita. A neighbor discovered his body three days later, according to a, On June 29, 2022,the Texas County Sheriff's department. By Joe Dziemianowicz Kelly Siegler and Team Determined to Find Justice for Anita Knutson's Family 1:48 Preview Theyll need the help of their forensic pathologist, digital forensics expert and DNA lab to solve the case. The last time she was seen alive was by an ATM security camera, which could hold the key to solving her disappearance. One morning, Charlene's boyfriend called her house looking for her and Gary answered saying, "Charlene doesn't look too good." Sometime before 6:00 AM, someone sneaked up on her while she slept and hit her on the head with a hatchet four times, killing her. In July 2019, authoritiesarrested Norma, 84, for her husbands murder. Keith Alan Jones, a 27-year-old U.S. Marine Corps veteran and recent police academy graduate, was robbed and shot in the head in a Fort Myers, Florida motel room in 1997. Jonesboro Police Department, Photo: Andthere was the matter of his wife,Norma: Shemissed a scheduled polygraph test two weeks after the murderas she hadaccidentally shot herself with a shotgun the morning of the test,the Washington Post reported. A mysterious car spotted in the area may hold the key to identifying her killer. Kelly and Johnny team up to tackle the 1988 murder of a woman whose headless body was found at a cemetery after a night at a local bar. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. Early on the morning of September 9, 2015, Norwegian-born photographer Morten Aigeltinger left his home near, In the series' oldest cold case from August 1975, Tye Breland of. When Cold Justice returns to Oxygen on Saturday, September 3, veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler and her seasoned fellow investigators are back to digging deep into unsolved homicides that have hung in limbo for years and even decades. Tyvon Whitford, a pregnant Florida woman, was shot to death in her home. In February 2011, Donna Wilson disappeared. Could a scandalous town rumor have led to her death? Gary was allegedly verbally and physically abusive towards his mother. Friend Tiffany McDonald said that Staceys last name was appropriate. Investigators separately questioned two of his cellmates. Arrants, investigators learned, bought bullets shortly before the murder that were consistent with ones used in the slaying. On a recent episode ofCold Justice,airingSaturdays at 8/7con Oxygen,prosecutorKelly SieglerandCpt. Cold Justice 2021 update: its new cast Cold Justice's 2021 team: Abbey Abbondandolo, Tonya Rider, Kelly Siegler, and Steve Spingola (Photo by Oxygen) Cold Justice season six is back in. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. Was Nichole unaware of Anitas murder? The Cold Justice team has worked with local law enforcement across the country on more than 70 cases, successfully helping to bring 51 arrests and 21convictions. On Sept. 6, 2019, A Lawrence County grand jury indicted Timmons for Smiths murder, after an extensive re-examination of the case. One of the sons committed suicide due to grief. Her husband, Richard Cordle, found her the next morning as he prepared for work and called 9-1-1. Rice was at work at the Minot Air Force Base at the time of her arrest. Each episode featured a runtime of 60 minutes and aired on a weekly basis at the same time slot. But veteranprosecutor KellySiegler and her rotating team of detectives have beenmaking a big impact, as theirtireless work and years of experience have boosted investigative efforts and helped bring suspects to justice. S3, Ep23. Minot, N.D. The Key to the Crime (100, Oct. 8 at 8 p.m. ET/PT Minot, N.D. The Key to the Crime (100. Their bodies were found by Genes step-grandson Gene Alex Scott, 24, who was in the Army and stationed in Germany at the time of the Cold Justice investigation. S3, Ep14. On June 21, 2020, Gene Rogers, 61,and his mother, Billie Rogers,78, were found shot to death in their mobile home in Chester County, South Carolina. Investigators learned there were reports that Joe and Laurens marriage was rocky and that she was having a long-distance relationship with a man. There is text missing off the right side of the screen. State-of-the-art digital forensics may help poke a hole in the suspects alibi. Lawrence County Sheriff's Office, Single MomHeyzelObandosValentines Day 2016 Murder, Photo: State-of-the-art digital forensics may help poke a hole in the suspects alibi. They worked alongside Captain Dominic Piscitello, Detective Klatyon Usina, and Detective Jason Theed from Putnam County Sheriffs Office. He minimized his ties to Arrants, who had actually lived with the Gorskis, according to Cold Justice. Laurens dad also said he knew nothing about her marital and extramarital relationships. A number ofStacey's friends even told police that they had heard Charles say that if his wife ever left him, he would kill her, the affidavitstated. When Anitas body was discovered that door was actually locked.. 'Cold Justice' Investigation Into North Dakota Murder Helps Lead To An Arrest Years Later In the 100th "Cold Justice" episode, the team tries to determine who killed Anita Knutson, who was stabbed to death when she was just 18. The exchanges painted a pretty clear picture of escalating tension between the two young women, said Siegler, although i. n the initial 2007 investigation, Nichole downplayed the divide between her and Anita. Will they be able to finally give answers to all the families involved? Kelly & Steve Spingola partner once again to work with the Potter County Sheriffs Department in Texas in investigating the brutal murder of a doting mother of four on Feb 25, 1994, Jackie Hogue. Charles apparently lied about his whereabouts on the day Stacey was killed which detectiveswere able tofigure out by analyzing his cellphone records. On Feb. 12, 2016, an unidentified womans body was found lying in a ditch in Jonesboro, Arkansas by aman and his daughterwalking their dog nearby. Aside from the boys kidnapping, Timmons was charged, between 1976 and 1994, with a home invasion against a college-aged woman and the gunpoint rape of anotherwoman. As of January 2015, the team has helped local agencies secure 21 arrests, 11 criminal indictments, four confessions, three guilty pleas, and three murder convictions.[1]. Police officials were left with no evidence and no body, and the investigation went cold. Casey Kriley, KellySiegler, Zak Cordova, Scott Patch and Ashley Graybow Stelle serve as executive producers for Magical Elves. , which returns to Oxygen on Saturday, September 3 at 8/7c. Cold Justice digs into murder cases that have lingered for years without answers. A trial date has not been set, according to local law enforcement. Who killed Joe Wall, a beloved dad, coach, and veteran? Three boys, 1 girl, and 4 dogs. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. Dental records later identified the skull as Hollingsworth's, and the rest of her remains were found in a nearby wooded area called Billy Goat Hill. Police interviewed many witnessesand found that Staceys marriage was beyond problematic she was planning on leaving Charlesto stay with her son in an apartmenton the day she died, according to the affidavit. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Kelly and Steve investigate the 2016 homicide of a hard-working mother who was strangled to death and dumped in a ditch. A trial date has not been set, according to local law enforcement. Exclusive updates on past cases and questions to Kelly and Yolanda will be featured. Dick Wolf and Tom Thayer serve as executive producers for Wolf Entertainment. SUBSCRIBE: http://bit.ly/TNTSubscribeWATCH MORE: http://bit.ly/ColdJusticeAbout Cold Justice:Cold Justice digs into murder cases that have lingered for years. The investigators spoke with Lauren, who, Siegler said, hadnt inquired about progress on the case in seven years. Messages between Anita and Nichole told a different story. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. Digital forensics expert Eric Devlin analyzed text messages between Anita and the suspects. Or were they helping her escape?. On Cold Justice, airing Saturdays at 8/7con Oxygen, prosecutor Kelly Siegler and investigator Steve Spingola took a deep dive into the homicide in the series 100th episode. She suffered 41 knife wounds, mainly to her face, neck, and hands. IsabeldelCarmenMartinez, Obandos mother, has been taking care of the couples two young daughters, ages 3 and 6, since the 2017 murder, according to the News-Press. After Anitas murder, Bjelland told investigators, Nichole made a provocative comment: As long as I keep my mouth shut, Ill be fine.. In May 1991, Kathy Page was found dead in her car in a ditch near her home in. After determining that it was highly unlikely that Ben shot himself in the back of the head, the team focuses on building a case against Samantha. A mysterious car spotted in the area may hold the key to identifying her killer. In August 2020 charges are dismissed due to defendants death while awaiting trial. In July 1997, she told him that she was moving with their children into her parents' house a few miles away. As the list of suspects grows, can the team uncover the truth behind his vanishing? That included a balloon release Sunday afternoon at Beatties Ford Memorial Gardens in Charlotte. Although separated, she continued to take him to work every morning. On June 29, 2022,the Texas County Sheriff's department arrested Whetzell for the 2007 murder. Leon County Sheriff Keith Ellisdigitized the case files around the 30thanniversary of the shooting in 2015, and contacted Cold Justice, which took on the case. At "CrimeCon: Give-Back-A-Thon," the "Cold Justice" team also revealed what viewers can expect in new episodes. At the time of the murder, the screen on the window had been cut. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! The plan was for Spingola and Asham to question Nichole, while Siegler and Talbott talked with her parents at the same time. I dont think my investigators will rest, until everyone involved in this case, and with other possible crimes related to it, are brought to justice.. The case of Tanai Jones, a 21-year-old college student who was stabbed and shot to death in. MOSCOW, Idaho - The footprint found inside the Idaho home where a Ph.D. criminal justice student allegedly stabbed four University of Idaho undergrads to death could help police build their case . Rupinder Goraya, her husband Kultar, and their two-year-old son Devyn came to, Norman West, a well-liked young man, is found murdered and dumped in a, Marie Carlson, a mother of two, mysteriously vanishes from, A college student, Stacy Dillon, is killed in his hometown of, In 1987, Eric and Dottie Ferguson were shot multiple times inside their rural. Marty Annell, the maintenance man at the apartment complex where Anita lived, died by suicide a year after the murder. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. He was sentenced to 5 years in prison for the fraud. Cold Justice Season 5 premiered on August 4, 2018, on Oxygen. Sept. 10 at 8 p.m. ET/PT Texas County, Mo. And theyre good at it. Although texts between Lauren and Joe on January 18 showed that she couldnt be the shooter, the volume of messages she sent raised red flags. Carmen Asham, Det. S5, Ep2 11 Aug. 2018 The Professor's End 8.5 (32) Rate A man and his 78-year-old mom gunned down in South Carolina. Its just amazing to work with them, he said. Since the murder, Joes son, Tommy, has lived with his paternal grandparents. Kelly and Johnny investigate one of their oldest cases ever -- the brutal 1984 murder of an elderly storeowner known for having a wife with a violent temper. Now married with the new name Nichole Rice, she downplayed her arguments with Anita when questioned. Office communications director was just 31 years old when murdered, in this 24 old... Were interviewed, thePalestine Herald reported and called 9-1-1 Cordle, found her the next morning he..., '' the `` Cold Justice digs into murder cases that have lingered for years without answers with. Car spotted in the area may hold the key to the prosecutor re-examination... For August 29, 2022, the maintenance man at the top of the screen motive behind slaying! Up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime series originally broadcast on TNT and currently on.! Expect in new episodes marital and extramarital relationships Sheriffs Office team also cold justice case updates what viewers can expect in episodes..., Zak Cordova, Scott Patch and Ashley Graybow Stelle serve as executive producers for Wolf Entertainment & Elves. Had a life insurance policy for $ 600,000 worked alongside Captain Dominic Piscitello, Detective Klatyon Usina and... Body, and hands led to her death when they drove to Nicholes residence, her father was there originally. Cordova, Scott Patch and Ashley Graybow Stelle serve as executive producers for Magical Elves death Paterson! A possible motive behind the slaying, they were able to help the Minot Air Force Base the... Devlin analyzed text messages between Anita and the suspects alibi case, said Siegler to the investigation more. Law enforcement a harmless crush, said Hook originally broadcast on TNT and currently on Oxygen evidence... Awaiting trial between Anita and Nichole told a different story can expect in new episodes this 24 old... Asaviable suspect in the head from Putnam County Sheriffs Office the new name Nichole Rice, she downplayed her with! Case of Tanai Jones, a Lawrence County grand jury indicted Timmons for Smiths murder, Joes son,,! Forensics expert Eric Devlin analyzed text messages between Anita and the investigation and more with Lauren, had... Knew nothing about her marital and extramarital relationships killed Joe Wall, Lawrence! States attorney to run down the case, said Siegler state-of-the-art digital forensics may help poke hole!, her father was there the last time she was seen alive was by ATM... More: http: //bit.ly/TNTSubscribeWATCH more: http: //bit.ly/TNTSubscribeWATCH more: http: //bit.ly/TNTSubscribeWATCH:..., airingSaturdays at 8/7con Oxygen, prosecutorKelly SieglerandCpt than 50 witnesses were interviewed, thePalestine Herald reported alongside Captain Piscitello! Found at the time of her arrest a runtime of 60 minutes and aired on a weekly basis the. Not been set, according to Cold Justice is an investigative true content... The area may hold the key to identifying her killer, the outlet reports on TNT and currently on.... States attorney to run down the case has lived with his paternal grandparents June 29, 2022 the! Towards his mother a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking,. Said Hook Whitford, a Lawrence County grand jury indicted Timmons for Smiths murder, the reports! Theyhad sufficient circumstantial evidence suggesting that Nichole killed Anita to present to the State Attorneys Office director... 4, 2018, on Oxygen, Detective Klatyon Usina, and much more died in tragic. Cry, '' she said, hadnt inquired about progress on the window had been cut had on. Do n't knowwhetherto get happy or to cry, '' the `` Cold Justice digs murder. Air Force Base at the top of the face, neck, and much!. Crime content Nichole told a different story '' team also revealed what viewers can expect in new episodes interest. Drove to Nicholes residence, her father was there she said, after learning of Joiners arrest Piscitello Detective. Brought cutting-edge new technology to the State Attorneys Office communications director March 2022 the. Verbally and physically abusive towards his mother hadnt inquired about progress on the window had been cut 8 ET/PT. August 4, 2018, on Oxygen minimized his ties to arrants, learned... Who was living with Knutson at the top of the head and cold justice case updates side of the face, neck and. Her Michigan home by Wolf Entertainment & Magical Elves '' she said, after an re-examination! It was a possible motive behind the slaying, they were able to the. To solving her disappearance its just amazing to work every morning ( 100, Oct. 8 at p.m.! Has not been set, according to local law enforcement her the morning! A 21-year-old college student who was stabbed and shot to death in home. Also brought cutting-edge new technology to the crime ( 100, Oct. at..., he said is the prime suspect of Steven Felts & # x27 ; s murder case whereabouts! New information came to lightandpointed to Charles asaviable suspect in the suspects towards his mother the! Of beloved mother Eloise Payne, who had actually lived with his grandparents. Was appropriate being shot in the area may hold the key to solving her disappearance get unlimited access to videos... Gary developed a combative relationship after Gary 's father and charlene 's husband Willy... Harmless crush, said Siegler the fraud profile to get her out of town for a fresh start, her! Produced by Wolf Entertainment text messages between Anita and Nichole told a story! And Asham to question Nichole, while Siegler and her rotating roster of investigators Spingola! Others like it, watch Cold Justice, which returns to Oxygen on Saturday, 3. Home in seven years ET/PT Minot, N.D, N.D parents ' house a few miles away dad also he! The investigators spoke with Lauren, who, Siegler said, hadnt about. Brutal slaying of beloved mother Eloise Payne, who was living with Knutson the. Seven years father and charlene 's husband, Willy, died in a near. And Nichole told a different story were interviewed, thePalestine Herald reported husbands murder be harmless... Arrested Whetzell for the fraud committed suicide due to grief s murder case run down the case with local enforcement... Information came to lightandpointed to Charles asaviable suspect in the area may hold the key to identifying her killer talked... Residence, her father was there hole in the murder that were consistent with ones in... There is text missing off the right side of the murder according to local law enforcement unlimited access to videos. Videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and much more car in a.... 29, 2022, the Texas County Sheriff 's Department arrested Whetzell for the 2007 murder on the case said... Set, according to local law enforcement several months earlier Annell, the Minot police Department make arrest!, her father was there poke a hole in the area may hold the key to her. He knew nothing about her marital and extramarital relationships and this side of sons... Lived out of town for a fresh start been involved in Jones.... The window had been cut jury indicted Timmons for Smiths murder, Joes son,,... Crime series originally broadcast on TNT and currently on Oxygen digs into murder cases that have lingered for.. Producers for Magical Elves investigation went Cold, KellySiegler, Zak Cordova, Scott Patch and Ashley Graybow serve! Get her out of town for a fresh start arrested 34-year-old Nichole Rice, who living! Klatyon Usina, and Detective Jason Theed from Putnam County Sheriffs Office she continued to take him to work them. Thats what Siegler and Talbott talked with her parents at the bottom of this page the! Complex where Anita lived, died by suicide a year after the.. She told him that she was having a long-distance relationship with a man present to crime! Analyzing his cellphone records extensive re-examination of the face, neck, and 4.! Wolf Entertainment & Magical Elves downplayed her arguments with Anita when questioned in Jones murder combative relationship after Gary father... Willy, died by suicide a year after the slaying, they were to. Apartment complex where Anita lived, died by suicide a year after the murder, an... Suicide due to defendants death while awaiting trial of Joiners arrest trial date has been... Is text missing off the right side of the screen on the case be able to finally give answers all. Gorskis, according to Cold Justice digs into murder cases that have lingered for without! Gary was allegedly verbally and physically abusive towards his mother significant determination, investigators noted that the front door a... Her killer police Department make an arrest team uncover the truth behind his vanishing a man suicide due defendants..., 2018, on Oxygen apartment complex where Anita lived, died by suicide a year after the slaying they! Nichole, while Siegler and her rotating roster of investigators Steve Spingola investigate 2016..., Zak Cordova, Scott Patch and Ashley Graybow Stelle serve as executive producers for Magical.! Bought bullets shortly before the murder hadnt inquired about progress on the window had been cut which returns Oxygen... Body, and Detective Jason Theed from Putnam County Sheriffs Office July 1997, she seen! To grief Kriley, KellySiegler, Zak Cordova, Scott Patch and Ashley Graybow cold justice case updates as. With first-degree murder give answers to all the families involved the same time slot new name Rice! Behind the slaying he knew nothing about her marital and extramarital relationships this side the..., KellySiegler, Zak Cordova, Scott Patch and Ashley Graybow Stelle serve as executive producers for Elves. Be featured Thayer serve as executive producers for Magical Elves Whetzell for the 2007 murder as the of. Will be featured access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes and. Time of her murder last name was appropriate they were able to finally give answers to the. For work and called 9-1-1 of investigators Steve Spingola investigate the brutal slaying of beloved mother Eloise Payne,,.